AI Won’t Fix a Weak Decision-Maker

AI Won’t Fix a Weak Decision-Maker

CEOs are warning that AI without hard thinking just gives you a faster version of yesterday. The tool doesn’t build judgment. The reps do. A discipline-of-thought episode.

A couple of weeks ago, the CEO of one of the biggest retailers in the world stood in front of a room of executives and said the biggest risk with AI is ending up with “a better version of yesterday.”

Her name is Malina Ngai, she runs AS Watson Group, and she wasn’t saying AI is bad. She was saying most companies are using it to make the same old process run faster. Same decisions, same blind spots, same weak spots. Just quicker.

The number that backs her up is rough. According to the Fortune piece where she said it, only about 5% of companies that have rolled out AI agents actually restructured how they work. Everyone else bolted a jet engine onto a horse cart and called it transformation.

I run a web agency. I use these tools every day. I also run a gym. And I’ve watched the same thing happen in both places for years, long before AI showed up. Somebody grabs a tool hoping it’ll do the hard part for them. It never does.

Speed multiplies whatever you already are

That’s the whole thing in one sentence. If you’re a sharp thinker, AI makes you sharper. If you’re sloppy, it makes you sloppy faster and with a lot more confidence.

I’ve watched a client want AI to fix a marketing problem that was actually a “we don’t know who our customer is” problem. The tool wrote gorgeous copy aimed at nobody. I’ve watched a guy at the gym buy the program, the app and the tracker and still skip the hard sessions. The tool didn’t make him disciplined. It gave him a nicer-looking record of not being disciplined.

The trap was never the tool. The trap is believing the tool did the thinking.

Judgment is the thing getting scarce

Another exec at that forum, Christina Zhu from Walmart China, made the point that AI makes the human more important, not less. Data can tell you what customers picked. It can’t tell you what they needed and never found. That takes a person who’s paying attention.

Judgment isn’t knowing the answer. It’s knowing which question matters, what to ignore, when the data is lying to you, and when to move before you have all of it. None of that comes from a prompt. It comes from having been wrong enough times, in enough situations, that you’ve built a feel for it.

Martial artists already know this. Anybody can learn a technique from a video. Knowing when to throw it, against this guy, in this moment, with this much gas left in the tank? That’s reps. Only reps.

How the people who make real calls actually train

Look at how special operators, first responders and fighters build judgment. They don’t train with the answer key. They train under ambiguity. Bad information, time pressure, real consequences. Then they debrief. Then they do it again.

Those people use tools constantly. Intel, comms, maps, data. But the tool feeds the decision. It never makes it. The second the tool makes the decision, you’re not a leader anymore. You’re a relay.

The crutch test

Here’s how you know which side of the line you’re on. Ask yourself: am I using this to sharpen my thinking, or to skip it?

Sharpening looks like this. You’ve already thought about the problem. You have a position. You hand it to the tool and tell it to attack it, find what you missed, or clear the grunt work so you can spend your energy on the call.

Skipping looks like this. You don’t have a position. You ask the tool what to do. It gives you something confident and plausible and you go with it, because it sounded smart and you didn’t want to sit in the discomfort of not knowing.

From the outside, both look identical. Only you know which one you’re doing.

Where AI belongs in a decision

It belongs in the research. Let it gather and summarize. That was always grunt work.

It belongs in the stress test. After you’ve made your call, let it argue with you. Great sparring partner. Terrible coach.

It belongs in the execution. Once the decision is made, let it draft and build and ship.

It never belongs in the decision itself. The moment where you weigh it, own it and put your name on it. That’s yours. Hand that over and you’ve handed over the one thing that made you worth following.

The reps that build a decision-maker

Decide before you ask. Write down what you’d do before you open the tool, then compare. Over time you’ll learn where your judgment is strong and where it’s weak.

Debrief your calls. Once a week, look back at the decisions you made. Which ones were you actually thinking on? Which ones did you just accept?

Sit in the uncomfortable part longer. Not knowing is where judgment gets built. The tool is designed to end that feeling as fast as possible. Don’t let it.

Own the outcome out loud. If it goes bad, “the AI suggested it” is not a sentence a leader gets to say.

The warrior take

The tool doesn’t build the judgment. The reps do.

A better version of yesterday is still yesterday. If you want a different tomorrow, you’ve got to do the thinking that’s uncomfortable, and nothing can do that part for you.

This week’s challenge: for seven days, before you use AI for anything that matters, write your own answer first. One line. Then ask. Then compare. At the end of the week you’ll have a map of exactly where you’ve been leaning on a crutch.

And read the Fortune piece. It’s short and worth it:
https://fortune.com/2026/09/15/ceos-ai-efficiency-trap-fortune-leaders-forum/

How Not to Be a Douchebag (A Martial Arts Debrief)

How Not to Be a Douchebag (A Martial Arts Debrief)

Cleaning out the inbox this week. A pile of clips and stories people have sent me have been sitting there long enough, so let’s debrief.

We start with the Jonah Hill jiu-jitsu clip that went viral, the perfect illustration of the Dunning-Kruger effect: a little training turns into “I can beat people up,” while the guys who’ve actually been on the mats for years get quieter and more humble the more they learn. Then the tech bros. Zuckerberg sparring on a custom floating platform in the middle of a lake, and how that stacks up against the story of his super-yacht reportedly passing on a distress call, when helping is one of the oldest rules on the water.

Then the one that got under my skin. Gordon Ryan taking a student’s purple belt and throwing it in a fire, on camera, as a “reward.” One of the best grapplers alive, and a masterclass in how not to treat people who trust you. We finish with the antidote: Gabriel Varga, five-time world champion, breaking down how a real professional spars with people who aren’t. Playful, controlled, take turns, let them learn. That’s the standard.

In this episode:

What good sparring actually looks like, from someone who’d know

The Dunning-Kruger effect and the blue-belt fallacy

Why the more you learn, the more you realize you don’t know

Performative toughness vs. the real thing

The unwritten (maybe written) rule of the sea and what it says about character

Why filming yourself humiliating a student makes the whole thing unserious

Tough Isn’t Enough: The Trap of Faking Strength

Tough Isn’t Enough: The Trap of Faking Strength

Toughness gets you into the fight. Resilience wins it. Two elite coaches, one dangerous lie, and the one question to ask yourself every morning.

Two runners from the same country, same talent, same fire. One stays elite for fourteen years. The other is done at twenty-seven. The difference wasn’t heart. It was how they spent it.

This episode of Warrior Mindset goes after the most dangerous lie in the tough-guy playbook: that a real high performer should be able to absorb unlimited stress, handle it alone, and never let off the gas. It feels like strength. A lot of the time it’s just pride wearing camo.

We put two elite coaches side by side. David Goggins, who teaches you to rip the governor off your mind and find the gear you didn’t know you had. And Firas Zahabi, the man who cornered Georges St-Pierre, who tells his fighters to train at seventy percent and never leave the gym sore. They give almost opposite advice, and they’re both right. It depends on the job.

We get into:

  • Toughness vs. resilience, and why most guys have only ever trained one of them
  • Where the “I can take anything” identity comes from and what it actually costs
  • Goggins as a breakthrough protocol, not a lifestyle
  • Zahabi, greasing the groove, and why recovery is the real bottleneck
  • The one question to ask every morning: Goggins day or Zahabi day?
  • What the research says about mental toughness as a buffer, not a bottomless tank
  • Three tools for intelligent energy management
  • This week’s challenge: find your tell

If you’ve been calling it heart while quietly running on empty, this one’s for you.

You’re Not Burnt Out. You’re Starving for Purpose.

You’re Not Burnt Out. You’re Starving for Purpose.

Most people who think they’re burnt out aren’t overworked. They’re under-purposed. This episode breaks down why rest isn’t fixing it and what a warrior does instead.

You took the vacation. You downloaded the meditation app. You fixed your sleep. And you still feel like you’re dragging yourself through every week.

Here’s the thing nobody tells you: that might not be burnout at all.

In this episode of Warrior Mindset, we dig into an idea from writer and entrepreneur Neil Thanedar that reframes the whole conversation. Burnout is what happens when you have too much load. But a lot of us are dealing with something different. We don’t have enough meaning. And you can’t rest your way out of that.

We get into:

  • Why the standard burnout fixes keep failing you
  • Viktor Frankl’s idea that meaning, not pleasure or power, is what actually holds people up
  • The “horseshoe” of stress and why a perfectly balanced life can still feel empty
  • The childhood dream test and what it reveals about what you’re really built for
  • Why students with the worst schedules are often the ones who never miss class
  • A practical plan to start feeding yourself again, one hour a week

If you’ve been calling it burnout and nothing’s working, this one’s for you.

Read the article that inspired this episode: https://neilthanedar.com/youre-not-burnt-out-youre-existentially-starving/